diet-lie

How many times have you heard someone say that a diet ‘worked’ but then later on they put the weight back on? Seems to me the diet didn’t work so well.

First Lie: Weight Loss is a Diet’s Success, Gaining the Weight is Your Failure

It’s kind of perfect isn’t it? If you lose the weight, the diet is proven effective, but if you put it back on it’s because of your own personal failure. But the reality is, for everyone who goes on a diet about 90% of them will not only put back on any weight they lose, they will put on a bit of extra weight as well. Diets are probably the only product you can sell to a consumer that doesn’t work but will still have them coming back for another round.

Second Lie: Just Count Calories and Exercise

It sounds easy, but really you know it’s not true. Because to believe this you have to believe that all calories are created equal. And they can’t be. Because the fact is that eating a chocolate coated ice cream is not the same as eating a vegetable stir fry. But the calories say they are the same. And it’s just not true.

Third Lie: If you are slim, you are healthy

This isn’t exclusive to the diet industry. There is a pervasive belief that how you look is an indicator for how healthy you are. But the fact is that you can be slim and internally obese and you can be obese and internally fit. There is no real way of knowing how healthy or unhealthy you are based on how you look. But it’s convenient to sell you this idea because then you have to be a certain weight to achieve a certain health factor. But the reality is that generally health benefits are linked to activity level, not weight loss.

Fourth Lie: Fat is bad for you.

If you believe this then it might shock you to know that low-fat dairy is a risk factor for obesity. It destabilises blood sugar, which is a key factor in food cravings. Because low-fat foods tend not to taste as good they often have added sugar and are less satisfying so you eat more.

Fifth Lie: Weight Loss is a Good Goal

It can seem like a good goal when part of what you want is to lose weight, feel a bit more comfortable. But the thing is, when you achieve that goal you don’t have it anymore, so you lose incentive and you lose motivation and you put on weight because food is yummy. And guess what? Come back, here is another diet for you.

Sixth Lie: You can train like an athlete and diet like a celebrity

Unfortunately you can’t. Eating for weight loss and eating for training are two very different things with very different goals. And you probably can’t do both at the same time. If you eat for training you will probably have very gradual weight loss, but that is all. And you would only want it to be very gradual because otherwise you would not be physically capable of getting the most out of your training. And if you severely restrict calories you just aren’t going to have the energy to train.

Seventh Lie: You don’t need to lose weight to start your life.

You don’t need to look a certain way to walk into a gym, or go for a run. You don’t need to look a certain way to get married or wear a bikini or wear a fancy dress.

Eighth Lie: The scales tell you what you need to know.

They don’t. They are probably the most inaccurate measure of where your body is at. They fluctuate based on hydration, what you ate, what you’ve had to drink, muscle composition and any manner of a million other things. So basing a set of goals based on that is a recipe for failure.

Ninth Lie: There is such a thing as ‘toning’

There isn’t. There is no such thing as toning. There is building muscle. Apparently ‘toning’ is the word used when describing women building muscle but there is no difference, it is all just building muscle.

Tenth Lie: Shame will Motivate You

Shame will not motivate you. Self-loathing will not inspire change. There is nothing wrong with you. Your body is capable of so much more than you believe it is.

If you want change, you have to love the body you have right now for everything it has already done for you and everything it is capable of doing in the future. You have to respect it. And appreciate it. And you have to believe in it. Food and exercise are not reward and punishment. There is no punishment. And you are the reward, just like you always have been.

So where does that leave you?

A while back I read a comment (I can’t remember the author unfortunately!) that said in response to restrictive diets that you should live the healthiest life you can enjoy, not the healthiest life you can. And that has stayed with me.

I think over the four years since I had my youngest I’ve made a lot of changes and they stuck because I enjoyed them and because they were small and just built up over time. The other part was that I set goals that weren’t weight-based. They were things like run further or run faster. Things that were easy to measure as a matter of performance, not aesthetics.

There is nothing wrong with weight loss as a goal – plenty of us at any given time might think I’d feel a bit more comfortable if I lost a bit of weight and there is nothing wrong with that. But often it’s actually representative of a different goal it might be that we want more energy because we are feeling sluggish, or we want to be able to have more stamina to keep up with our kids or it might be that we want to run a little faster or have more confidence in ourselves. So my approach is that I focus on those things and everything else follows.

If you want to change, a diet is a setup for failure. Start by choosing the life you want and see where that leads you instead.

“I like what running does for me, even when I’m not running.”

Learn to Run starts on the 13th March

Claim your spot today and join the team that is going to support your goals in 2017

Are you ready to take your running to the next level?

Check out Run Club, our Custom Plans or Far and Fast Running Coaching.

Zoey Dowling

Written by: Zoey Dowling

You may also like these posts

Leave A Reply:

(optional field)

  1. This is just what I needed to read. As I'm struggling with the fact that my body is getting bigger and changing with all my training and calories that I need to consume. Although still struggling with eating the right foods.

  2. Great post, and I have to agree with all of it. Not all diets are the same, and not all will work for everyone. Some love low carb high fat, others love paleo, others eat in moderation. You know what works for you. Go with that.

  3. Pingback: Is this a conversation you have with yourself? Me too. May 27, 2015

    […] contrary to what you might be told there is no lean muscle or bulky muscle. There is just muscle. There is no toning. There is just building muscle. And it doesn’t matter whether you do high repetitions at low […]

  4. Pingback: Does running for weight loss work? Here's an even better idea | Operation Move June 19, 2015

    […] you need is to consume less calories than you expend. But the reality is that it is more complex. Not all calories are created equal. A lot of it depends on your metabolism. And sometimes the challenge with starting running is that […]

  5. Pingback: The one question that gets asked the most about Learn to Run | Operation Move August 12, 2015

    […] fail people. Because they aren’t flexible, or because they are too restrictive, or because they put you on a starvation diet that sets you up to fail or simply because they confuse weight loss with […]

  6. Pingback: Podcast: Episode 8 - Day on a Plate | Operation Move June 8, 2016

    […] We don’t believe in diets, or running for weight loss but we do believe in living the healthiest life you can enjoy. […]